Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Thanksgiving Orders 2026
Pick-up will be on Wednesday November 25th, from 11 AM-6 PM at the Humble Pie Airstream located next to Family Footwear on Northside Dr in Bennington VT.
Dinner Rolls
Brioche Dinner Rolls (dozen)
Soft, rich dinner rolls with a slightly sweet flavor
$12.00

9" Deep Dish Pies baked in our Signature Shortbread Crust
Apple Crumb
Local Cortland & Macintosh apples baked to perfection with warm spices, in shortbread crust with a crunchy streusel top.
$35.00

Traditional Blueberry
Double-crusted pie made with Wild Maine blueberries lightly sweetened to perfection, in shortbread crust.
$30.00

Bourbon Pecan
Nutty, gooey Pecan Pie baked with Vermont Maple Syrup and notes of Bourbon in a shortbread crust. Made without corn syrup.
$35.00

Maple Custard Pie
A rich baked custard pie made with local Vermont Maple Syrup, topped with whipped cream dollops.
$30.00

Gluten-Free Maple Custard
A rich baked custard pie made with local Vermont Maple Syrup, topped with whipped cream dollops, in gluten-free shortbread crust. Made in kitchen containing gluten.
$40.00

Chocolate Creme
Rich chocolate custard nestled in a shortbread crust, topped with fresh whipped cream and chocolate cookie crumble.
$35.00

Pumpkin Pie
Traditioan Pumpkin Pie baked with warm fall spices and molasses, topped with fresh whipped cream dollops.
$25.00

Toll House Pie
Rich Chocolate chip cookie pie baked in a shortbread crust, with walnuts and Chocolate Chips.
$35.00

Peanut Butter Pie
Peanut Butter Mousse pie with Chocolate Shortbread crust, topped with Whipped Cream, drizzled with Chocolate Ganache & crushed Peanuts.
$35.00

.png)